Asking the Uncomfortable Question: Are Museums Ever Really Neutral?

Behind every vitrine is a decision, and that decision was never neutral

A normal visitor may see museums as neutral custodians of a shared human heritage: a place where objects simply exist to be observed. It is natural to think that museums do not take sides in history – just simply exist as a space for displaying the past/history so that the audience can make their own judgments; hence, may think that museums are neutral. But are they really? Quite the opposite: museums are not neutral spaces.
Why is it so? Consider what McLean¹ writes:
Even in the earliest temples of the muses, someone set forth some object for others to experience, and who selected what for whom is the question at the heart of all conversation about exhibitions. The objects may be trophies of conquest, curious things from the natural world, masterpieces, or constructed environments, but embedded in their presentation is material evidence of the presenter’s intentions and values.
What this tells us is that the presentation of objects is already value-laden: It reflects the perspectives of curators and the institutions that have the authority to shape or guide visitors’ understanding in a certain way. Some scholars even argue that neutrality for museums is impossible to achieve since there is no such thing as “a view from nowhere” – all views must come from somewhere.²
For example, imagine a museum displaying a 19th-century farming tool. It could be labeled simply as "Plough, c. 1850, wood and iron". In this case, the object is presented as a piece of craftsmanship or technology. Or it could be labeled as "Plough used on a plantation worked by enslaved laborers" – in this case, it is presented as evidence of a system of forced labor. The intention of curators in the museums matter. Curatorial practice is a way of telling a story about what is being displayed. Depending on the intention of the curators and the institutional authorities, multiple stories can be told about the same objects.
Museum controversies
Because museums inevitably make choices about what to display and how to frame it, they are never neutral – and because those choices touch on contested histories, they are prone to controversy.
One recurring controversy concerns the way museums have framed historical narratives in accordance with the interests and values of dominant authorities. Museum scholars have examined how colonial-era collections were presented in ways that celebrated national conquest and mastery, often using exhibition arrangements to suggest the superiority of the colonizing nation over the societies from which the objects originated.² ³
In other words, 19th-century museums did not simply display objects from distant places as curiosities. They often arranged and interpreted them in ways that made their own nations appear advanced and powerful, while portraying other societies as primitive or "behind". These descriptions reflected colonial hierarchies rather than the realities of the cultures being represented.
For example, Franz and Méndez⁴ examine how the Witte Museum in San Antonio, Texas, presented Anglo pioneers as heroic founders of the state in its early exhibitions during the 1920s–1940s. The Anglo pioneers were presented as heroic founders of the state and displayed their weapons as symbols of courage and protection against "lurking Indians" -- this was an effort to erase the marginalized voices (i.e., of Indigenous peoples, Tejanos, and ethnic Mexicans) while normalizing Anglo supremacy and violence.
But museums as well as curators can (and should!) do better: museums can become sites of decolonization by centering Indigenous knowledge and perspectives, confronting the difficult truth of colonization in their exhibitions and acknowledging the continuing effects of colonialism. This is something scholar Amy Lonetree⁵ has called for, particularly in relation to the representation of Native American histories and communities.
The challenge of decolonizing museums persists because simply adding more information about marginalized communities in exhibitions is insufficient. Meaningful decolonizing practices also involve sharing curatorial authority with Indigenous communities, recognizing their interpretations of history/worldviews and acknowledging the museum's own role in colonialism. This is quite a challenging task because it can question established institutional practices and national narratives, potentially provoking political resistance or discomfort among visitors.
Contemporary museums are increasingly taking on this challenge. The Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of the American Indian (NMAI) is one example. Established as a national museum dedicated to Native American peoples and cultures, the NMAI represents an important development in recognizing Native histories and perspectives within the museum landscape.⁶
The museum also works directly with Native and Indigenous communities in its collection care and exhibition practices. It involves Native community members in consultations concerning the documentation, conservation, treatment and display of cultural objects. Its wider community engagement also includes collaboration on exhibitions, educational materials and public programs.⁷
These practices demonstrate how Indigenous knowledge and perspectives can become part of museum decision-making, rather than simply being presented as additional information for visitors. Although scholars continue to question whether museum exhibitions fully address colonialism and its lasting effects,⁶ Smithsonian's collaborative initiatives mark a significant and encouraging development in the ongoing process of decolonizing museum practice.
Another recurring museum controversy concerns collections of looted cultural artifacts and artworks. If curatorial choices can shape the meaning of an object already in a collection, the same is true of the choice to acquire and retain that object in the first place. Many of the world's most visited museums hold collections containing objects acquired through colonial conquest, military violence and coercion. Their presence in museum collections is not simply a matter of preservation; it also reflects histories of unequal power and colonial appropriation.
The Benin Bronzes are among the best-known examples. During the British invasion of the Kingdom of Benin in 1897, the British force looted an estimated 5000 pieces from the royal palace and other locations in Benin City, in what is now southern Nigeria. These objects were subsequently dispersed through sales and transfers into museum collections and private collections across Europe and North America. They are commonly referred to collectively as the "Benin Bronzes", although the term encompasses objects made from various materials, including brass, ivory, wood and bronze. They are of immense cultural and historical significance to the Kingdom of Benin and the Edo people. The British Museum houses the biggest collection with over 900 objects, while German institutions, prior to their recent restitution, held up to 1,100.⁸ ⁹
Calls for the return of the Benin Bronzes have been made for decades. In 2010, the Benin Dialogue Group was established, bringing together European museums and Nigerian partners, including representatives of the Edo State Government, the Royal Court of Benin and the National Commission for Museums and Monuments (NCMM). The group provides a framework for dialogue and cooperation concerning the future of the objects and their return to Benin City.¹⁰
Since then, some progress has been made in terms of restitution, although the process has been slow. Museums and governments worldwide are gradually taking action.
In 2022, Germany and Nigeria reached an agreement concerning the restitution of approximately 1,130 objects held by German institutions. As part of this process, ownership of 512 objects from Berlin's Ethnological Museum was transferred to Nigeria. Around one-third of these objects remained in Berlin on loan, while others were physically returned in stages.¹¹
More recently, in June 2025, the Netherlands completed the restitution of 119 Benin objects to Nigeria: 113 from the Dutch State Collection and six from the municipality of Rotterdam. The objects were handed over to the Nigerian government, which will determine how and where they are displayed.¹²
These examples of restitution represent important steps towards addressing historical injustices and should put further pressure on other museums that continue to hold objects looted during the 1897 invasion, including London's British Museum, to reconsider their position on returning them.
The debate is not simply about where these objects should be kept. It is also about recognizing the cultural heritage of the Edo people, the historical role of the Benin Royal Court and the perspectives of the Nigerian institutions and communities involved in determining their future. Restitution is therefore not just a matter of transferring objects between museums and governments, but also of recognizing the people and histories to which these objects belong.
What does it mean, then, for us as museum visitors?
It means we shouldn't walk through a museum assuming what we see is simply the objective truth. Every object, every label, and every decision about what is included or left out reflects someone's choices and carries a point of view. That's not necessarily a bad thing. But it does mean that a little healthy skepticism is in order: asking ourselves who told this story, whose perspectives are represented, and whose experiences might be missing.
Bibliography for academic articles and books
McLean, K. (1999). Museum exhibitions and the dynamics of dialogue. Daedalus, 128(3), 83–107.
Macdonald, S. (2003). Museums, National, Postnational and Transcultural Identities. Museum and Society, 1(1), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.29311/mas.v1i1.3
Evans, H. J., Nicolaisen, L. B., Tougaard, S., & Achiam, M. (2020). Museums beyond neutrality. Nordisk Museologi, 29(2), 19-25.
Franz, K., & Méndez, V. A. (2023). The Witte Museum and Frontiers of Public History: Building Stories of Anglo Supremacy, 1920s–1940s. In U.S. Museum Histories and the Politics of Interpretation. Routledge.
Lonetree, A. (2021). Decolonizing Museums, Memorials, and Monuments. The Public Historian, 43(4), 21–27. https://doi.org/10.1525/tph.2021.43.4.21
Lonetree, A. (2012). Decolonizing museums: Representing native America in National and Tribal Museums. The University of North Carolina Press.
Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian. Community Engagement and Conservation Outreach
British Museum. Collecting Histories.
National Museums Scotland. The British Raid on Benin 1897.
Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz. Benin Dialogue Group Statement.
Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz. Return of the Berlin Benin Bronzes.
Government of the Netherlands. Benin Bronzes from the Netherlands returning home to Nigeria


